Senator John McCain has upped the anti in the debate over Iraq. He is now calling the Democratic position of proposing a phased withdrawal from Iraq a “betrayal.” But a betrayal of whom, and by whom; that is the question?
In truth, I agree with him. The entire War in Iraq has been a “betrayal,” but the primary “betrayal” is under the collective ownership of George Bush, Dick Cheney, Don Rumsfeld, and John McCain, who have betrayed the American people more fundamentally than any administration since the War in Vietnam.
The Betrayal of Trust:
We elect our officials to treat us with at least some minimal standard of honor, honesty and decency. We expect them to tell us the truth, and telling the truth does not include creating and manipulating facts to support a decision that they had already reached for entirely other reasons. If the people we elect accept no such minimal standard, they are betraying not just our trust for today, but the trust of everyone who gave so much to create the place we call the United States of America. It is a truly terrible betrayal, and certainly one that we will have a hard time explaining to our children.
Senator John McCain is a perfect example of the Biblical exhortation; the sins of the father are oft visited upon the son. John McCain was betrayed. He served honorably and even heroically in Vietnam, in another War that was based on betrayal; where the premise for the war was a fabrication based on deceit, dishonesty, false doctrine, manipulation, and perjury. I assume that he is literate enough to have read the Pentagon Papers, which were commissioned by then Secretary of Defense, Clark Clifford, and which lay out the ugliness of the betrayal involved with the Vietnam War. Clearly, John McCain, the young pilot, was betrayed by his government when he deserved better.
But Senator McCain, shame on you; shame on you for suggesting that honorable men and women, citizens like you, who find this war a betrayal of our heritage and our values to be somehow suspect. Before you charge us all with “betrayal,” you need to consider the massive fabrication that was and is required to justify this war in the first place.
The Betrayal By the Iraqi Government:
We all know that Saddam Hussein betrayed his people. There is no disagreement on that. What we are faced with now, however, is a continual betrayal in the form of a government in Iraq that refuses to take the most minimal steps required for national reconciliation. We have given them with the blood of our children and their children a new opportunity. What do we get for that blood and a large part of our national wealth? We witness daily the corruption, the theft of oil, the fat cats in the bureaucracy who feed at the public trough, the indifference to the minimal requirements we set for our continued participation, and the willingness to put personal and sectarian objections higher than any national reconciliation. Equally, we see our own political corruption exposed daily – huge contracts to dubious contractors whose primary claim to fame is their closeness with this administration, massive theft on a scale that simply defies our imagination, and mismanagement on a level that seems unmatched in modern time.
You know the old expression: “With friends like these, who needs enemies?” So who is the betrayer? Look no further than the governmental officials who show you around on your trips to Iraq, or to the slick contractors in their fancy clothes and polished flattery, who laugh behind your back at your remarkable naiveté and lack of sophistication. They are the betrayers – they fool you and the Bush Administration, and they betray the trust of their own people who clearly deserve better, and they betray the trust of the American people who are providing them with an opportunity for freedom. How many more American lives do we owe them – 4000, 8000, how many? What Senator McCain is your bottom line, or is there really no bottom line other than a situation that can allow the Republicans to declare some sort of victory before they pull out?
The War without End:
George Bush and Senator McCain offer only a single strategy – war without end, without achievable objections, and without regard for the consequences for either the Iraqi people or the American people. You have only one answer for everything – more troops, more weapons, more violence, and more patience. That has been the trouble with you and your friends in the Bush Administration from the very beginning. They have only one answer for the threats we face in an Al Qaida world – the extension of our massive retaliation doctrine from the Cold War in a different form. The administration takes great delight in the accuracy of our precision bombing; they demonstrate no understanding at all of how to piece the armor of the human heart.
There is no subtlety of thought in this administration; no appreciation of the complexity of the threats we face; and no real understanding of the role that our values play in fighting a battle of values. George Bush prefers a world in which he can go, gloriously, on the deck of aircraft carrier in a flight jacket to proclaim the war over and the job done.
The real betrayal is for this Country to continue fighting a war where the lives of our children are thrown away for no good cause or reason. We are fighting a war where the “end game” is a pure fantasy that captivated the remarkable international naiveté of the Bush Administration – an idyllic, childishly romantic view of a thriving American style democracy in the heart of the Middle East, engineered with American military prowess and created by American multi-national war companies. President Bush and his colleagues, including John McCain, will go into history as among the most naïve and ridiculous group ever to occupy the White House. They would be as laughable as the “gang that couldn’t shoot straight,” except for the fact that it is Iraqi and American children who are getting hit with their misfired bullets.
There is Plenty of Betrayal to Go Around:
Senator John McCain is a right wing conservative, who takes every opportunity to call himself just that. If you want to find betrayal in Iraqi, what about these betrayals:
The betrayal of the trust and honor of our American values.
The betrayal of the values of honesty, decency, and honor when you lie to the American People.- The betrayal of honesty with our soldiers, who were told repeatedly that this was going to be over quickly and decisively so that they could go back to their families.
- The betrayal of the misuse of our national wealth.
- The betrayal of our commitments to confer with our allies and honor the good opinions of our friends.
- The betrayal of the hundreds of thousands of Iraqi’s who have paid with their lives for our mistaken approach to dealing with Saddam Hussein.
- The betrayal to our Secretary of State, who was tricked into delivered an entirely false statement to the United Nations.
- The betrayal to the Constitution of condoning unwarranted searches and seizures and of incarcerating people without trial or without recourse to our courts.
- The betrayal to the economic well being of the American people by following economic policies to finance this war that will undermine the economy of the United States for years to come.
- The betrayal to our children and grandchildren for financing this entire war with a national debt for which they will be held accountable.
The Iraqi War is clearly a betrayal. There is no question about that and we agree. You have much to answer for, Senator McCain, and you are far more clearly in the camp of the betrayer than you are among the betrayed. With great irony, you served very honorably and heroically in the Vietnam War in which you were betrayed by two previous Administrations both of which used fabrications, false doctrines and ideologies, and outright corruption to sustain and continue a war that was a mistake from the very beginning. Now, you are yourself involved in a second great betrayal of the trust and values of the American people and you are allowing yourself to become an agent of the same type of fabrication of which you were once the victim. Like your predecessors with regard to Vietnam, you claim that those who oppose this Administration are engaged in betrayal. Have you no shame, Senator? Have you no shame?
Just my opinion!
Gordon Black
